Head-to-head, season-long, or the shared-goal challenge that turns out to be the fun one. A short guide to using FanThrill as a weapon in a group chat that has needed settling since college.
Three shapes of a challenge
- Head-to-head, one game. You and one other person, tonight only, most points wins. Fast, personal, and over before anybody can claim they were not really trying.
- Season-long. A running total across every game either of you plays. Rewards consistency and punishes the friend who only shows up for nationally televised games.
- Shared goal. Everyone in the challenge pools points toward one target. You win or lose together, which changes the entire tone of the chat.
Most people start with head-to-head because it is the obvious one. The shared-goal format is the one that keeps groups together.
Why shared goal is the sleeper
Competitive formats have a structural problem: the person in last place stops playing by week three. A shared target does not have that failure mode. If the group needs 1,500 points together, the friend having a bad night is still contributing, and the person carrying it has a reason to keep going rather than coast.
It also produces the specific and slightly ridiculous experience of texting somebody at 10pm to tell them a reliever is warming up because you need eighty more points.
The thing people get wrong about points
Putting points on a pick never reduces the total your crew sees. Friend standings count points you have earned, which means playing aggressively cannot hurt your standing with the group.
People assume the opposite, play conservatively for three weeks, and then discover they left a rank on the table for no reason. Read that line on the Friends screen once and it saves you a month.
How to actually start one
Add friends by handle or code from the Friends tab, hit New challenge, pick a format and a target, and send it. Live standings update during the game, so the trash talk has receipts attached in real time rather than the next morning.
Etiquette, briefly
Do not start a season-long challenge with somebody who watches four times as much sport as you and then complain about it in August. Do not screenshot a two-point lead in the third inning. And when you lose, lose in the chat — the whole point of a scoreboard is that it is public.
*Prizes awarded through points redemptions and periodic sweepstakes drawings. No purchase necessary. Odds of winning a drawing depend on the number of eligible entries. See Official Rules.